Jump to content

Photo

National Hockey League 2011/2012 Thread


  • Please log in to reply
45 replies to this topic

#41
acasser

acasser

    Rookie

  • Member
  • PipPipPip
  • 190 posts
  • Locationnorthern New Jersey

The Devils don't have any stand out players this year. (Barring perhaps Kovalchuk, but he's been very streaky this season). Why would a skills competition feature sub par players? That just doesn't make sense... It's supposed to have the best players in the league.


The skills competition features that year's All-Stars -- outside roughly a dozen rookies, nobody goes to the Skills Competition unless they're playing in the game itself.

Patrik Elias is 16th in the NHL in scoring. Ilya Kovalchuk and Zach Parise are both in the Top 40. As a team, the Devils are roughly middle-of-the-pack -- 8th in the Eastern Conference, and 18th in scoring. I understand the Devils' aren't an NBC favorite, I understand that Gary Bettman personally dislikes the Devils' organization. Still, there's a league custom that "every team gets a representitive". Heck, that's why Carey $@*%ing Price got named an All-Star -- if you look at his numbers he isn't even in the top half of NHL goaltenders this year, but Montreal had to have a representitive (and Raphael Diaz was only added when Adam Larsson pulled out with an injury). Look at some of the other guys who were named "All Stars" this season -- Dan Girardi, Logan Couture, Jason Pominville. Jason Spezza and Milan Michalek (fan voting, admittedly, but the ability to stuff the ballot box distorts things and neither guy deserves to be there over a bunch of other players from other teams).

If you want to abolish the "every team must be represented" rule, fine. But come out and say it, instead of screwing over two teams that deserved to be represented. You could have taken a Devil and justified it over some of the fourth and fifth players from other teams who made it. Same for Winnipeg -- Evander Kane belongs in Ottawa this weekend. There are teams who were given a rookie as a throwaway and didn't get a player into the real game.

#42
BeautifulTorment

BeautifulTorment

    Advanced

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 668 posts
  • LocationCanada
I never knew there was a rule stating that every team has to be represented. On two of the points you've made though, I agree. Montreal's players don't necessarily deserve to be in the all-star game this year, but since Montreal has one of the largest fan bases in the league, and with all the shit that's been happening surrounding the franchise, it was expecting that someone would go to the game regardless.

As for Spezza and Michalek? Of course they don't belong there. This voting thing was new to the process, I think, and should be abolished. The Ottawa Senators have some good players, but half their team shouldn't be in here.

Posted Image
Posted Image


#43
Dreakon139

Dreakon139

    Pro

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,723 posts
  • LocationBuffalo, NY

Look at some of the other guys who were named "All Stars" this season -- Dan Girardi, Logan Couture, Jason Pominville.

Hey, the Sabres don't have much to enjoy this season... let us have this. :lol:

Gone the way of the PC. If you use Steam, you should add me as a friend!

Steam ID: dreakon


#44
BeautifulTorment

BeautifulTorment

    Advanced

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 668 posts
  • LocationCanada
So Team Chara won... It was pretty clear the better team for sure. I think they were told to let up a little bit so Alfredsson could share the limelight.. Right silly that is! I was hoping for an embarassment.

Posted Image
Posted Image


#45
Ewok_3000

Ewok_3000

    Newbie

  • Member
  • Pip
  • 15 posts
  • LocationChristchurch, New Zealand

As for Spezza and Michalek? Of course they don't belong there. This voting thing was new to the process, I think, and should be abolished. The Ottawa Senators have some good players, but half their team shouldn't be in here.

Sorry for replying a little late, but it's definitely not new. There was a lot of ballot stuffing in the 2009 All Stars Game, when 6 Habs players were nominated, and 4 made it to the starting lineup. Those Habs players that made it in were Kovalev, Komisarek (who at the time only had 3 points), Markov and Price. It just comes to show that if the ASG is in Canada, there's gonna be a LOT of ballotstuffers.

Anyway, I'm a Sharks fan, and I'm disappointed with the way they're playing right now. They're barely holding on to stay in the top 8.

#46
DanielVT

DanielVT

    PSNP Top Poster

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,132 posts
  • LocationVermont, United States of America
I can't wait for the season to start even if it is shortened. I expect the Bruins to go far this year. The rankings have them in the top three. It will be interesting to see how Rask does full time since Thomas chickened out of the season.

Also, since Dreakon does not seem too active here anymore (we miss him) I will start the 2013 thread.

Posted ImagePosted Image



0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users