This trophy and  Chair the Load are both obtained in the “Moon Market” side story. See  Bookworms for information on where to find side stories.


After finding the first cat and bringing it to the locked door, Zoe and Mio will gain access to the marketplace plaza where three cats escape down three pathways. A potion stall can be found on the right side of this plaza as pictured above. One or both players, collectively, must cook all six recipes listed on the board to the right of the cauldron. After drinking each potion, they'll temporarily transform into different forms, such as a cloud or a cat. Upon consuming the sixth unique potion, both players will unlock this trophy.